「無料翻訳ソフト」の実力くらべ (第5回)

関係代名詞、関係副詞 (和文英訳)

今回は和文英訳を試してみました。

● 原 文 ●
1. 今彼は元ミスカリフォルニアの女性と交際しています。
2. 夫が有名な医者である女性がきのう誰かに殺された。
3. 私が一緒に働いている女性は、仲良くやってゆくのにむずかしい人なんです。
4. マクドナルドは人気が世界中に広がっているアメリカのファーストフード・チェーンです。
5. 営業成績が落ち始めた近所の銀行が、新しいお客をひきつけるために特別サービスをしている。
6. この製品が飛ぶように売れるとは私は夢にも思わなかった。
7. あなたはこの本を10頁から20頁まで、読みさえすればよいのです。
8. これは私のおじさんの一人が、元支店長として働いていた銀行です。
9. 彼がここへ来るときまでに、全部準備ができているようにしてください。
10. 私がアメリカ研究を選んだ理由は、アメリカをよく知ることが英語を徹底的に勉強するのに不可欠であることを知っていたからです。

【エキサイト翻訳】
1. He is associating with the woman in former Miss California now.
2. The woman whose husband is a famous doctor was killed by yesterday someone.
3. The woman that I am working together is a person difficult though it does happily.
4. McDonald is a fast food chain in the United States that catches on worldwide popularity.
5. Special is served so that the bank in the vicinity where business results began to fall may attract a new guest.
6. I did not think the dream to sell as this product flew.
7. You only have to read this book from page 10 to page 20.
8. In this, one of the uncles of me is a bank that worked as a former general manager.
9. Everything must be prepared by the time of which he comes here.
10. The reason why I chose American studies is that it knows it is indispensable so that knowing the United States well may thoroughly study English.

【Yahoo! 翻訳】
1. He associates with a woman of former mistake California now.
2. The woman who was the doctor that a husband was famous was murdered yesterday by somebody.
3. The woman whom I commit together is a person hard to please to do it peacefully.
4. The McDonald is the American fast food chain which popularity spreads through all over the world.
5. I give a service in particular so that the neighboring bank where has begun to lose a business grade attracts a new visitor.
6. I never dreamed that these products were selling like hot cakes.
7. You have only to read this book from page 10 to page 20.
8. This is the bank which one of my uncles committed as a former branch manager.
9. By time when he comes to here, please be all ready.
10. The reason why I chose Americanology as is because I knew that it is indispensable to know U.S.A. well to study English thoroughly.

【翻訳@nifty】
1. He has associated with the woman of former Miss California now.
2. The woman who is a doctor with a famous husband was killed by someone yesterday.
3. The woman whom I am committing together is a person difficult for doing with sufficient relations.
4. McDonald’s is a fast food chain of the United States where popularity has spread all over the world.
5. In order that the bank of the neighborhood from which business results began to fall may attract a new visitor, its service is given specially.
6. I never thought that I sold so that this product may fly.
7. You are what has only to read this book from 10 pages to 20 pages.
8. This is the bank which one of my uncles was committing as a former branch manager.
9. When he comes here, are all ready and please make [ by ].
10. The reason I chose American Studies is that it knew that it was indispensable for getting to know the United States well to study English thoroughly.

【Google 言語ツール】
1. Now he has associated with the original mistake California woman.
2. The woman who is the doctor where the husband is famous killed in yesterday someone.
3. The woman where I work together, although you do chummily, is the difficult person.
4. MacDonald is the fast food chain of America where popularity is spreading in the world.
5. The bank of the neighborhood where business result starts falling, has serviced especially in order to be accustomed to pulling your new customer.
6. In order for this product to fly, it can sell, with as for me you did not think even in dream.
7. It means that you, only reading should have done this book from page 10 to page 20.
8. This one person of my uncle, is the bank where it worked as a former general manager.
9. When he comes to here to, preparation that please makes sure does entirely.
10. Because the reason where I choose the American research although knowing America well studies English thoroughly had known that it is indispensable is.

【OCN 翻訳ツール】
1. He’s associating with the female of Miss former California now.
2. My husband was killed in who the lady who is a famous doctor was yesterday.
3. I’m a difficulty person in the lady’s working together being on good terms and managing.
4. McDonald’s is the American fast food restaurant where popularity is spread in all over the world and a chain.
5. A bank in the neighborhood open results have begun to fall where gives its service especially to attract a new visitor.
6. I didn’t also think these products sold so that it might fly in a dream.
7. You need only to read this book from 10 pages to 20 pages.
8. This is the bank where one person of my uncle was working as a former branch manager.
9. Please be ready completely by the time when he comes here.
10. The reason that I chose a American studies is because I found to know the United States well indispensable to study English thoroughly.

*人間による翻訳*
1. Right now he’s going out with a girl who’s a former Miss California.
2. A woman whose husband is a well-known doctor was killed by someone yesterday.
3. The woman I’m working with is very difficult to get along with.
4. McDonald’s is an American fast-food chain whose popularity has spread all over the world.
5. The neighborhood bank whose business started to drop off is now offering special services to attract new customers.
6. This is the last product I’d have expected to sell like crazy.
7. All you’ve got to do is read from Page 10 to Page 20.
8. This is the bank where one of my uncles used to work as branch manager.
9. See to it that everything is ready by the time he gets here.
10. The reason why I chose to study American studies was because I knew that a good knowledge of America was mandatory for studying English through and though.

今回の「勝手ランキング」は英国人ネイティブに頼んでつけてもらいました。人間の翻訳を100点としたら、それぞれ何点になるかを聞いてみましたが、「点数をつけることは難しい。ただ【エキサイト翻訳】は6と8を除くその他の文章は、なんとなく意味が想像できるので、印象的だった」とのコメントをもらいました。

1位 【エキサイト翻訳】
2位 【Yahoo! 翻訳】
3位 【OCN 翻訳ツール】
4位 【翻訳@nifty】
5位 【Google 言語ツール】

(この項、続く)